5 Myths That Had Me Fooled (Until I Shopped on Amazon in My Pajamas)

I really appreciate you checking out my blog! Just so you know, some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means that if you buy something through them, I might earn a little bit of money, at no extra cost to you. There’s absolutely no pressure to buy anything, but if you do, it genuinely helps support the time and love I put into writing these posts.

I’ll be honest: I used to think “clean beauty” was just a fancy way of saying “rub coconut oil on everything.” Like, if it didn’t come in a mason jar or smell like eucalyptus, it clearly wasn’t doing much. But then I started paying attention—like really reading the labels, noticing how my skin felt, and let’s not lie, panic-Googling ingredients at 2 a.m.

Somewhere between breaking out from a “natural” turmeric face mask and spending $60 on a rosewater spray that smelled like salad dressing, I realized I had fallen for a lot of myths about clean beauty.

So here it is: my very real, very relatable list of the 5 biggest myths I believed about clean beauty—and what I now use instead (yes, with actual Amazon links because I love you and also Prime).

Myth #1: “If it’s clean, it won’t work.”

I used to believe this with my whole heart. Like, if it didn’t sting or smell like chemicals, it couldn’t possibly be doing anything. Right? Wrong.

I remember using this harsh salicylic acid face wash in college that smelled like nail polish remover and thinking, “Ah yes, the burn means it’s working.” Meanwhile, my skin was red, angry, and dry enough to flake off mid-conversation.

Now I use the Acure Brightening Facial Scrub and guess what? It’s made with sea kelp and lemon peel, and my skin glows without feeling like I rubbed it with sandpaper.

It’s gentle, smells like a spa, and actually does something magical to my dull skin.

Myth #2: “Clean beauty = DIY beauty.”

This one nearly sent me into full meltdown mode. I spent one too many Sundays mixing honey and cinnamon into questionable pastes that made my kitchen smell like chai and disappointment.

It’s romantic to think you can whip up a glow mask from your pantry, but let me save you the clogged pores and ants.

Now I swear by Herbivore Botanicals Blue Tansy Mask. It’s got natural AHA/BHA from fruit enzymes and feels like the cool cousin of all those messy kitchen experiments—but it works better and doesn’t drip down your neck while you try to binge-watch “Bridgerton.”

Myth #3: “If it’s natural, it’s always safe.”

Oof. This one got me good. I once used a 100% pure essential oil directly on my face (rookie mistake) and ended up with a rash that looked like a geography map.

Just because it’s “natural” doesn’t mean it belongs on your skin. Poison ivy is natural too, you know?

Now I look for products that are clean but also dermatologically tested and well-formulated. My favorite facial oil that doesn’t make me look like a glazed donut is the Biossance Squalane + Vitamin C Rose Oil.

It’s made from sugarcane-derived squalane, it’s super hydrating, and the vitamin C actually helps fade my acne scars—without any scary surprises.

Myth #4: “Clean beauty has to be expensive.”

Hahahaha. Cue nervous laughter as I recall that $84 eye cream I used for a week before it made my under-eyes puff up like marshmallows.

Look, some clean brands are pricey, yes—but there are so many affordable, clean options now that don’t require you to refinance your apartment.

Enter: Burt’s Bees Truly Glowing Gel Cleanser.

It’s under $10, has clean ingredients, and my skin drinks it up like water after a night out. Pair it with their Sensitive Daily Moisturizing Cream and you’re glowing and not broke.

Myth #5: “Clean = fragrance-free.”

This one confused me for years. I thought clean meant everything would smell like cardboard. But fragrance (when done right) can be safe and delicious-smelling.

What matters is whether the fragrance is synthetic and toxic—or naturally derived and safe for sensitive skin.

I live for the Native Coconut & Vanilla Deodorant. It smells like a tropical smoothie, is aluminum-free, and actually works (even on summer days when I’m stress-sweating through Zoom calls).

Also, Pacifica Island Vanilla Perfume? Clean, light, and makes you smell like you’ve been sipping iced coffee on a beach. Zero synthetic junk.

Final Thoughts: Clean, but make it real

Clean beauty isn’t about perfection or purity or having a shelf full of bamboo jars. It’s about being more mindful—choosing products that make you feel good without making your skin freak out or your wallet cry.

I still mess up sometimes. I still get tempted by a $75 serum with gold flakes in it. But now I know how to read the ingredient list, how to tell hype from helpful, and how to find amazing, clean products—without leaving my house (or my sweatpants).

And honestly, that’s the real glow-up.

If this post made you go “Wait, same,” then welcome to the clean beauty club. It’s cozy here. Bring your own jade roller. Or don’t. That’s also fine.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases, but this does not affect my recommendations.I only suggest products I’ve personally vetted.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending