How perfectionism quietly fuels anxiety and how to calm it down without becoming a “zen person”

I really appreciate you checking out my blog! Just so you know, some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means that if you buy something through them, I might earn a little bit of money, at no extra cost to you. There’s absolutely no pressure to buy anything, but if you do, it genuinely helps support the time and love I put into writing these posts.

I used to think perfectionism was just having “high standards.”

That’s what I told myself while rereading the same email five times, fixing commas no one would notice, and replaying conversations in my head at night like they were courtroom evidence. I wasn’t anxious, I said. I just cared.

But here’s the thing no one tells you early on: perfectionism doesn’t feel like confidence. It feels like pressure. And over time, that pressure turns into anxiety.

If you’ve ever thought, Why can’t I relax unless everything is done? or Why does my brain treat small mistakes like personal failures?—you’re not broken. You’re likely stuck in the perfectionism–anxiety loop, and it’s incredibly common in high-functioning adults.

Let’s talk about why perfectionism fuels anxiety, how it sneaks into everyday life, and how you can start breaking the cycle with a few simple, practical tools—no dramatic personality overhaul required.

Why perfectionism and anxiety are basically roommates

Perfectionism sounds productive on the surface. It whispers things like, Do better, Try harder, Don’t mess this up. But under that voice is a deeper fear: If I’m not perfect, something bad will happen.

For me, it showed up as constant mental math.

If I say the wrong thing, will they judge me?

If I miss a detail, will it reflect badly on me?

If I rest, am I falling behind?

That’s anxiety doing push-ups behind the scenes.

Perfectionism trains your nervous system to stay on high alert. Your brain starts treating normal, human moments—typos, unfinished to-do lists, awkward pauses—as threats. And when your brain thinks there’s danger, it doesn’t relax. It scans, tightens, overthinks, and loops.

Over time, this creates a cycle:

• You aim for perfect to feel safe

• Perfect becomes impossible

• Your anxiety increases

• You double down on control

• You feel even more anxious

And somehow, even your downtime feels stressful.

How perfectionism sneaks into normal life (without you noticing)

Perfectionism isn’t always color-coded planners and straight-A energy. Sometimes it looks like:

• Procrastinating because you want to “do it right”

• Avoiding starting something new because you might fail

• Feeling guilty for resting when things aren’t finished

• Replaying past conversations to check if you sounded “off”

• Setting goals that leave no room for being human

I remember sitting down to relax, phone in hand, and realizing my shoulders were still tense. Nothing was wrong. But my body hadn’t gotten the memo that it was allowed to stand down.

That’s when it clicked: my standards weren’t motivating me anymore. They were exhausting me.

Breaking the cycle doesn’t require “letting go of standards”

This is important: breaking free from perfectionism does not mean lowering your values or becoming careless. It means shifting from control to support.

Think of it like this—anxiety thrives in environments where your brain never feels “done.” So the goal isn’t perfection. The goal is giving your nervous system signals of safety and completion.

Here are a few simple tools that helped me do exactly that.

1. A physical boundary for mental overthinking

Amazon product: A paper daily planner or simple to-do notebook

I resisted this for a long time because I thought, I already have everything in my head.

Turns out, that was the problem.

Writing things down—on paper—created a physical boundary for my thoughts. When tasks lived only in my brain, they felt endless and urgent. On paper, they became finite.

I started using a simple daily planner where I wrote three priorities max. Not ten. Not everything I “should” do. Just three things that would make the day feel complete.

Here’s the magic part: once they were done, I closed the planner. That physical act gave my brain permission to rest. Anxiety loves open loops. This helped close them.

2. Teaching your body how to calm down (not just your mind)

Amazon product: A weighted blanket

I didn’t buy a weighted blanket for anxiety. I bought it because everyone on the internet said it was “cozy.” What I didn’t expect was how much quieter my body felt underneath it.

Perfectionism lives in the mind, but anxiety lives in the body. A weighted blanket provides gentle pressure that signals safety to your nervous system—similar to a hug you don’t have to explain yourself to.

Using it at night helped my body settle faster, which meant fewer racing thoughts and less mental rehearsal of the day’s mistakes. It didn’t fix everything, but it softened the edge.

Sometimes calm doesn’t come from thinking differently. It comes from feeling supported.

3. Interrupting the spiral with one honest page

Amazon product: A simple guided anxiety or mindfulness journal

When perfectionism flares up, my thoughts tend to blur together. Everything feels urgent and personal. Journaling gave those thoughts somewhere to land.

I’m not talking about writing a novel. Just one page a day—often answering prompts like:

• What am I worried about right now?

• What’s actually in my control?

• What’s “good enough” for today?

Seeing my thoughts in ink made them less intimidating. It reminded me that anxiety speaks in absolutes, while reality usually lives somewhere in the middle.

The mindset shift that changed everything

The biggest change wasn’t the products. It was the question I started asking myself:

Is this about doing my best—or about trying to avoid discomfort?

Perfectionism often isn’t about excellence. It’s about fear of judgment, failure, or letting someone down. Once I saw that, I could choose a different response—one that was kinder and more sustainable.

Progress didn’t come from pushing harder. It came from learning when to stop.

If this resonates, you’re not alone

If you’re reading this and nodding, that tells me something important: you’re self-aware, thoughtful, and trying to do life well. Those are strengths—not flaws.

I write about topics like this regularly—mental health, habits, and the quiet patterns that shape our daily lives—in my newsletter. It’s where I share practical insights without the pressure to “fix yourself,” just real conversations about being human in a demanding world.

If that sounds like something you’d want in your inbox, I’d love to have you there. No spam, no perfection required.

Perfectionism doesn’t mean you care too much. It means you’ve been carrying too much alone. And the moment you start offering yourself support instead of pressure, anxiety loses some of its grip.

So tell me—what’s one small place in your life where “good enough” might actually be enough?

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases, but this does not affect my recommendations.I only suggest products I’ve personally vetted.

One response to “Chasing Gold Stars Is Exhausting”

  1. Seems like you’ve peeked into my world over the past two weeks. I’ve experienced so many of the things you mentioned, and you’re right, perfectionism has been the culprit.😩

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending